Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Why the Stimulus Plan Won't Work: And several ideas that might

I'd queued this story up a few days ago but haven't had a chance to post it until now. The stimulus package has passed, so now it's so what? but here's some doomsaying that ought to be considered:
The theory of economic stimuli suffers from several serious problems. First, it assumes people are stupid. Tax rebates, for example, presume that if people get money to increase their consumption, businesses will expand their production and hire more workers. Not true. Even if producers notice an upward blip in sales after the rebate checks go out, they will know it's only temporary. Companies won't hire more employees or build new factories in response to a temporary increase in sales. Those who do will go out of business.

Second, the thinking behind stimulus legislation assumes that the government is better at spending $800 billion than the private sector. When President Obama says, "We'll invest in what works," he means, "unlike you bozos." The president's faith in Washington is charming, but politics rather than sound economics guide government spending. Politicians rely on lobbyists from unions, corporations, pressure groups, and state and local governments when they decide how to spend other people's money. By contrast, entrepreneurs' decisions to spend their own cash are guided by monetary profit and loss. That's likely to work better and certain to produce more innovation.

But the biggest problem is that the government can't inject money into the economy without first taking money out of the economy. Where does the government get that money? It can either borrow it or collect it from taxes. There is no aggregate increase in demand. Government borrowing and spending doesn't boost national income or standard of living; it merely redistributes it. The pie is sliced differently, but it's not any bigger.


The idea's that might work? Tax cuts. Corporate tax cuts, specifically, but no one wants to hear that.

Well, it's passed and signed into law. That's the political process. Let's give it a chance and see if it works.

1 comment:

  1. Ooooh, that was a good article! I esp like that last statement.

    ReplyDelete